Wildrose + PC = Federal Conservative voters in Alberta, right?
Actually, it’s Wildrose+PC plus plus plus
A few surprising things about the federal election in Alberta:
- Almost a half-million more people voted in the federal election, compared to the May 2015 provincial election
- Despite their huge win in May, the NDP lost votes compared to their previous federal effort in 2011, including a significant drop in ‘market share’
- And the most surprising to me – the federal Conservatives had 375,000 more votes than the two ‘conservative’ provincial parties (PC and Wildrose) combined.
Chart: Comparing the 2015 Alberta provincial results to 2015 Alberta federal results in TOTAL VOTES. Note: Wildrose and PCs combined and compared to federal CPC.
For those who prefer the raw numbers:
|Provincial Party||2015 AB PROV||Federal Party||2015 AB FEDERAL||Difference|
|PC + Wildrose||773,082||CPC||1,148,649||375,567|
|Total Voters||1,486,901||Total Voters||1,929,197||442,296|
So, 442, 296 more Albertans voted in the federal than the provincial, despite the fact that the Alberta provincial election was a once-in-a-generation change. These ‘new’ voters didn’t necessarily march to the polls to trounce Harper – there was a bit of that – but many may have been small ‘c’ conservatives sitting out the provincial election. While the provincial turnout was higher than normal at 58%, the federal turnout this month was 69%.
Comparing Alberta federal results: 2011 to 2015
Leaving the May 2015 provincial election aside for a moment, both the Conservatives and Liberals made gains in total votes, while the NDP was flat. Because turnout was much higher, the NDP and Conservatives lost market share while the Liberals went way up.
Chart: Comparison 2011 to 2015 federal results in Alberta by VOTES
Chart: Comparison 2011 to 2015 federal results in Alberta by market share
The Liberals go way up in votes and market share; the Conservatives go up in votes and down in market share; and the NDP are flat in votes and go down in market share.
What does it all mean?
Well, you gotta be dispirited if you’re an NDPer. On the surface, it makes the May 2015 results look very fleeting and surely there were hopes last May of a “Quebec-Alberta bridge” that could have delivered a federal NDP win, a’ la Mulroney 1988 and many PMs in the past.
Don’t despair, orange friends. When you look at it a little deeper, a combination of federal NDP and federal Liberal voters makes for a significant voting bloc, one that is larger than the NDP vote from last May.
It’s a salivating prospect for non-NDPers in Alberta to consider how to harness the power of the federal Conservative voting bloc. It remains the most dominant political base in the province, but has been divided provincially in recent years. Also, just because some Notley voters would have voted CPC doesn’t mean they won’t return to Notley next election.
Governing well is the key to success for Premier Notley. She will need to try to not awake the Beast – those million-plus federal Conservative voters. She cannot do much to keep the conservative base from unifying – that’s on them, and it won’t be easy given the cultural differences at the provincial level between PCs and Wildrose.
On her end, she will be very keen to unite ‘progressive’ voters and appeal to those 473,661 federal Liberal voters that were energized by Justin Trudeau, most of whom residing in Calgary and Edmonton who largely voted for her last May. Putting all her eggs in the NDP-brand basket is a non-starter in Alberta.
The Premier of Alberta making nice with a Prime Minister named Trudeau… now that would be something.
A panel discussion of the Alberta election hosted by the Broadbent Institute